Differences
This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.
| Both sides previous revision Previous revision Next revision | Previous revision | ||
|
history:beta_17:nations:treaties_on_reform_of_the_alpha_nations_charter [2011/09/13 10:58] yugotexas [Responses] |
history:beta_17:nations:treaties_on_reform_of_the_alpha_nations_charter [2020/11/08 04:02] (current) |
||
|---|---|---|---|
| Line 118: | Line 118: | ||
| =====Responses===== | =====Responses===== | ||
| - | You cannot coup an international organization. You either launched an attack on Kurwa, or took over headquarters located on international grounds, in which case you simply aren't to be recognized as the legitimate authority of the AN and so there is no point voting on your resolutions. This is a game and there is no incentive to over-think an imaginary organization's charter. We were willing to bend the rules and play along with you, but unfortunately you went too far and Alpha saw fit to ban you. Nations and organizations like the AN are not features of the server but are entirely voluntary social creations used by some players to make the game more enjoyable through roleplay. International law is not above the admin/mods, is not set in stone, and is not for others to play at lawyer with. --- //[[|Sikandar]] 2011/09/13 10:36// | + | You cannot coup an international organization. You either launched an attack on Kurwa, or took over headquarters located on international grounds, in which case you simply aren't to be recognized as the legitimate authority of the AN and so there is no point voting on your resolutions. This is a game and there is no incentive to over-think an imaginary organization's charter. We were willing to bend the rules and play along with you, but unfortunately you went too far and Alpha saw fit to ban you. Nations and organizations like the AN are not features of the server but are entirely voluntary social creations used by some players to make the game more enjoyable through roleplay. International law is not above the admin/mods, is not set in stone, and is not for others to play at lawyer with. --- //[[minecraft17:nations:start|Sikandar]] 2011/09/13 10:36// |
| + | ===== Official AN Response ===== | ||
| <WRAP column 50%> | <WRAP column 50%> | ||
| This supposed loophole to 'abuse' of Article 3 is closed by ''**Article 4, Chapter 1, Section 4**'' requiring there be more than one sponsor to a bill against fellow members which resolution 1488 was\\ | This supposed loophole to 'abuse' of Article 3 is closed by ''**Article 4, Chapter 1, Section 4**'' requiring there be more than one sponsor to a bill against fellow members which resolution 1488 was\\ | ||
| \\ | \\ | ||
| - | ''Each and All members of the Alpha Nations shall have the right to introduce and sponsor resolutions except: […] 4. it's unilaterially introduced and entails action against a member state, in which case it shall be required co-sponsors for it to come to a vote''\\ | + | ''//Each and All members of the Alpha Nations shall have the right to introduce and sponsor resolutions except://\\ |
| + | //[…]//\\ | ||
| + | //4. it's unilaterially introduced and entails action against a member state, in which case it shall be required co-sponsors for it to come to a vote//''\\ | ||
| \\ | \\ | ||
| As for Ex post facto, this is implied, even if it was explicit, Alpha would still not be effected by it due to the fact he is God\\ | As for Ex post facto, this is implied, even if it was explicit, Alpha would still not be effected by it due to the fact he is God\\ | ||
| Line 135: | Line 138: | ||
| for ''**Article 5**'', this was only to be used in response to **''Article 9''** events or major events between voting sessions such as your coup of the AN\\ | for ''**Article 5**'', this was only to be used in response to **''Article 9''** events or major events between voting sessions such as your coup of the AN\\ | ||
| \\ | \\ | ||
| - | To ''**Article 9**'', for a NWO conspiracy theorist like your self, if you actually read closely it you should have noticed something else… “''resolutions passed by the AN shall [now] be applicable to that state including sanctioning of military action outside of the rules of engagement and legal dissolving of that state with a resolution''”, no where does it state this same action can not be applied to member states with ''**Article 4, Chapter 1, Section 4**'' even giving the legal means to introduce such a resolution, but of course, even then there's safeguards considering a single Veto instantly kills the bill\\ | + | To ''**Article 9**'', for a NWO conspiracy nut like your self, if you actually read closely it you should have noticed something else…\\ |
| - | //- YugoTexas// | + | \\“''//resolutions passed by the AN shall [now] be applicable to that state including sanctioning of military action outside of the rules of engagement and legal dissolving of that state with a resolution...//''”\\ |
| + | \\ | ||
| + | No where does it state this same action can not be applied to member states with ''**Article 4, Chapter 1, Section 4**'' even giving the legal means to introduce such a resolution, but of course, even then there's safeguards considering a single Veto instantly kills the bill\\ | ||
| + | //**//- YugoTexas//**// | ||
| </WRAP> | </WRAP> | ||
| - | + | ---- | |